Skip to content

Choose which kinds of cookies and similar tools we may use. Your choice is saved on this browser for six months.

Follow-Ups

How to Email a List of Leads and Follow Up

You have a spreadsheet of people to contact and no sales tool. Here's how to email each one from Gmail and follow up until they reply, step by step.

Mixmax 2 min read

To email a list of leads and follow up until each one replies, put the list into a sequence: a set of emails that send from your own Gmail on the days you choose. You write the first email and two or three follow-ups once. Each person gets their own email thread, the follow-ups go out on schedule, and they stop for anyone who replies. Mixmax is a lightweight outreach tool inside Gmail that does this, and the free plan covers 50 people a month.

Why a mail merge isn’t enough

A mail merge sends one personalized email to everyone on a spreadsheet. The hard part comes after: working out who answered and who didn’t, then sending each follow-up by hand. With 200 people on a list, that’s where follow-ups get missed. A sequence does that part for you. Mail merge vs. a follow-up tool goes into the difference.

What you need before you start

  • Your list in a spreadsheet, one person per row, with an email column and anything you want to mention: first name, company, how you know them.
  • A Gmail or Google Workspace account. The emails send from your own address, so replies land in your normal inbox.
  • Three or four short emails: a first email and two or three follow-ups.

Step by step: from a spreadsheet to a sequence in Gmail

  1. Clean the list. One person per row, an email address in every row, and plain column names like First name and Company. Those column names become the fields you can drop into your emails.
  2. Sign up for Mixmax with your Google account (free, no credit card). It works inside the Gmail you already use.
  3. Create a sequence and write the emails. Write the first email, then each follow-up. Insert variables like first name or company so each email reads like you wrote it for that person.
  4. Pick the days. For example: the first email today, a follow-up three days later, another a week after that. Follow-ups go out as replies in the same thread.
  5. Add the people. Import your CSV, add them from Salesforce or HubSpot, or type them in. Each column in your file lines up with a variable in your emails.
  6. Review and start. Read a few emails as they’ll actually go out, fix anything that looks odd, then start the sequence.

From then on, each person moves through the emails on their own schedule. Anyone who replies stops getting follow-ups, and you answer them from Gmail like any other email. Sequences has more on how it works.

Start free with Google

What to write in each email

  • First email: who you are, why you’re writing to this person, and one clear ask. Keep it short enough to read on a phone.
  • Follow-up 1, two or three days later: one line that brings the email back up, plus one new reason to reply.
  • Follow-up 2, about a week later: something useful, like an example, a link or an answer to a likely question.
  • Last email: a short, friendly close (“I’ll leave it here, but if the timing changes, just reply”).

Three or four emails is plenty. For wording, see follow-up email templates for no response and how many follow-up emails to send.

How to see who’s interested

Mixmax tracks opens and clicks, so you can see who opened your email, who clicked a link and who replied. The live feed lists every tracked email you sent and what happened to it, and each sequence shows how many people opened, clicked and replied. Someone who opened your email three times but hasn’t answered is worth a personal note.

What it costs

PlanWhat you getPrice
Free50 sequence recipients and 20 tracked emails a month, plus follow-up reminders$0
Paid100 recipients a month on the first step, up to 15,000 on the top one, with unlimited tracking and all core featuresFrom $29 per user per month billed yearly ($34 monthly)

Every paid plan starts with a 14-day free trial. Details are on the pricing page.

Keep your emails out of spam

  • Send at a normal pace. A sequence spreads emails over days instead of sending everything at once. Gmail also limits how many emails one account can send a day (Google’s sending limits).
  • Personalize more than the first name. One line about why you picked this person does more than any subject-line trick.
  • Keep the list clean. Remove addresses that bounce and anyone who asks you to stop.
  • Warm up a brand-new account first. See how to warm up a Gmail account for cold outreach.

Frequently asked questions

How do I follow up with a list of leads until they respond?

Put the list into a sequence. Write the first email and each follow-up once, pick the days, and import your list. Each person gets the follow-ups on schedule, and they stop as soon as that person replies.

What tool do I need to email a list of leads and track who’s interested?

A tool that sends from your own inbox, follows up on a schedule and shows who opened, clicked and replied. Mixmax does this inside Gmail, and you can start on the free plan.

I have 200 leads and no sales tool. What should I use?

You don’t need a CRM to start. A spreadsheet and a follow-up tool in Gmail are enough: import the 200 rows into a Mixmax sequence and write three or four emails. The free plan covers 50 people a month. Sending to all 200 in one month takes the 500-recipient step, $49 per user per month billed yearly.

Can I do this with Gmail alone?

Partly. You can send each email yourself and use snooze or nudges to remember follow-ups, but Gmail can’t send a follow-up for you or stop when someone replies. See does Gmail have automatic follow-up?

Will people who already replied keep getting follow-ups?

No. When someone replies, the rest of their sequence stops.


Keep reading:

Mixmax

Posts from the Mixmax team — practical guidance from sales reps, managers, and leaders building pipeline and closing deals inside Gmail every day.